Retailers, both large and small, are grappling with an alarming increase in store crimes, ranging from petty shoplifting to large-scale organized theft that clears entire shelves of products. The repercussions of this trend have been significant, with Target projecting a loss of half a billion dollars this year due to escalating theft. Nordstrom, Whole Foods, and other major chains have even decided to abandon San Francisco, citing changing economic conditions and concerns over employee safety. Numerous retailers have attributed store closures to the surge in crime.
While it is unclear whether crime rates are substantially growing, industry experts suggest that as economic fears intensify amidst inflation and rising borrowing costs, shoplifting tends to rise as well. The combination of need and opportunity acts as a potent catalyst for the increase in retail crime.
Criminologist Read Hayes, from the University of Florida and the director of the Loss Prevention Research Council, explains two types of store theft plaguing retailers. Firstly, there is a trend of inexperienced individuals resorting to theft of basic necessities like bread and meat. Secondly, there is organized retail crime, where crews take advantage of specific opportunities to steal items for resale online, at local shops, or street fairs. Inflation plays a role in triggering shoplifters. Although inflation has been gradually cooling, prices in the United States continue to rise. This puts budget-strapped consumers under additional strain, unable to afford groceries, transportation costs, home bills, and credit card debt. A recent Gallup poll revealed that 61% of Americans are experiencing financial hardship due to rising prices, with lower-income households feeling the greatest strain. Mark Cohen, director of retail studies at Columbia Business School, highlights the multi-layered nature of escalating retail crime, reflecting social distress in society. He suggests that the current period is characterized by the legitimization and normalization of bad behavior, with gun violence, civil discord, and polarization among Americans on the rise. Retail crime becomes an unfortunate consequence of these societal issues.
According to the National Retail Federation, large-scale store theft accounts for a significant portion of annual retail shrinkage, which refers to merchandise that goes missing due to theft, fraud, damage, or other reasons. In 2021, total annual shrink reached $94.5 billion, up from $90.8 billion in 2020, with nearly half attributed to large-scale theft. Retailers experienced an average increase of 26.5% in this type of theft compared to the previous year.
Retailers, including Target, are grappling with the magnitude of the challenge. The CEO of Target, Brian Cornell, emphasized that the issue affects the entire retail industry, limiting product availability, creating an inconvenient shopping experience, and posing risks to employees and customers. Target has been facing numerous incidents of shoplifting and organized retail crime across its stores nationwide, with frequently stolen products including necessities such as soaps and shampoos.
While individual retailers are taking measures to address the problem, Target believes that it is an industry-wide issue that requires collective action. However, proving the gravity of the problem can be challenging, as opinions within the industry differ. Walgreens, for instance, recently shifted its stance on store theft impacting its business, suggesting that the problem may have been overhyped. Nonetheless, retailers remain vulnerable to shoplifting, posing ongoing challenges to their profitability and operations.
The surge in store crimes highlights the pressing need to address social and economic issues that contribute to this problem. Collaborative efforts between retailers, communities, and policymakers are crucial to ensure a safe and sustainable retail environment for both businesses and consumers.
Comments